Apoie!

Seja aliada da Pública

Seja aliada

Agência de Jornalismo Investigativo

Police in Quedas do Iguaçu are arresting MST supporters who occupy land to protest against timber company Araupel and cattle ranchers

28 de setembro de 2017

The small town of Quedas do Iguaçu, in southern Brazil close to the border with Paraguay, awoke to the sound of helicopters on November 4 last year. After eight months, a police investigation aimed at an alleged criminal conspiracy within the Landless Workers’ Movement (MST) was about to come to fruition. Sixteen arrest warrants were issued – 14 of them against members of the MST – in three police investigations.

The linking of these investigations was made possible by a law called the Criminal Organisations Act, which was initially intended primarily to combat organized crime such as drug trafficking and money laundering. Since coming into force in 2013, it has also been used against street protesters in Rio de Janeiro and defendants in the vast Car Wash corruption probe.

The MST, which was formed in 1984 here in the state of Paraná, is long used to conflict. The direct-action movement of 370,000 families has occupied an estimated 18.75 million acres of land in a country where rural poverty is common and land ownership is deeply unequal. Under certain circumstances, Brazilian law allows for the appropriate of unused land but the response from landowners and police has often been violent.

Seven members of the MST were remanded in custody that morning, the second time that law had been used against the movement in a few months. “The MST has always been criminalized. In the past, they accused them of forming gangs, for example,” said Fernando Prioste, a legal advisor to Terra de Direitos, a human rights NGO, adding that the law allows the authorities to link varied allegations back to supposed leaders. “It is also an accusation that increases the penalty in the case of a conviction.”

In Quedas do Iguaçu, occupations began in 1996 and the region has since gained one of the highest concentrations of families who have benefit from agrarian reform of anywhere in Brazil. According to the National Institute of Colonization and Agrarian Reform (INCRA), about 10,000 people live on more than 53,000 hectares of claimed land here and in a neighboring municipality.

The lands were legally appropriated from Araupel, a logging firm – and there are another 30,000 hectares that remain – for now – in the hands of several farmers and the company. It is this land that is at the centre of the current conflict, and the police investigation called Operation Castra.

José Cícero da Silva/Agência Pública
Regulations posted in the camps led to accusations that the MST was illegally coercing people and even forming private militias

The police investigation began after a complaint to public prosecutors from a resident of an MST camp, who reported that the movement had armed patrols. The report was passed onto the state government led by Governor Beto Richa – whose 2014 reelection campaign received BRL 150,000 (GBP 35,236) from Araupel – which then ordered the police to investigate “reports of various crimes.”

On March 8 last year, MST activists protesting against “the destructive model of agribusiness and its impacts on the environment” invaded a pine and eucalyptus seedling nursery owned by Araupel. Within half an hour, according to a police document, damage worth BRL 936,000 (GBP 219,909) was done to seedlings, sheds, furniture and a mobile laundry. A fire within the nursery caused further damage, according to police.

The next day, the MST targeted a nearby 2,000-hectare family farm for occupation, with the farmer’s son telling police that 30 militants had taken the farm over at 5am armed with shotguns. In another invasion the next day, two workers said the 15 militants were armed. MST members deny using firearms in their direct actions. “It was a peaceful occupation. It was not turbulent or threatening,” one activist present said. No weapons said to have been used in the action have been recovered by police.

Days later, police merged all three investigations under the Criminal Organisations Act. According to detective Anna Karyne Turbay Palodetto, there was evidence that elements within the MST were “associating [with each other] in an organised manner for the purpose of committing crimes.”

José Cícero da Silva/Agência Pública
In 2015 farm settlements in western Paraná produced more than 150,000 litres of milk per day

Despite being labeled as vagabonds by farmers and local press, the MST’s settlements are thriving. They plant organic corn, cassava, pumpkin, rice and beans, and build houses, churches and schools. In 2015, settlements in the region produced 150,000 liters of milk a day. “It is criminal for you to have such a large area and only plant pine,” said Elemar Cezimbra, an academic and a MST coordinator in Paraná.

“They came to kill us” from Agência Pública on Vimeo, part of its report ‘Crime or Conflict‘, interviews two survivors of the killing described below, who refute the police version of events.

Soon after all those events, on April 7, tragedy struck the MST camp. Police shot dead two landless laborers, Leonir Arback and Vilmar Bodin, and injured another seven. In total 128 shots were fired and all but one of the victims was shot from behind. Police said the MST members had fired first whereas the landless labourers said the police opened fire unprovoked.

Two seriously injured militants were taken to hospital. ”From the moment of the killings, we were barred from talking to the wounded,” said Claudemir Torrente Lima, a lawyer who defends MST members. “They were isolated, we made several attempts to talk to them and it was not allowed.”

Two MST members were arrested and charged with illegal possession of firearms and the attempted murder of police officers. Two firearms were recovered – the only ones found in any of the probes. Federal Police were brought in to investigate, and concluded it was impossible to tell who fired the first shot. No police officers have been indicted.

Reprodução
Left to right: state deputy Paulo Litro (PSDB-PR); Adriano Chohfi, delegate of Operação Castra; Head of the Parana state administration Valdir Rossoni and Tarso Giacomet, Director of Araupel

The deaths did not affect Operation Castra, which continued wiretapping MST members for eight months. Other accusations were fed into the investigation, including the claim from a farmer that the MST had stolen 1,300 cattle from his farm costing him BRL 5 million (GBP 1.18 million), which MST activists dismiss as a logistical impossibility.

Of the 16 people sought by the authorities, seven were remanded in custody on November 4. On May 17, a judge ordered their release. Prosecutor Leonir Battisti, however, said the charge they had formed a criminal organisation was well-grounded. “There are a number of people who happened to be in the movement and who behaved in a criminal manner. If they had a social purpose, it does not matter. Even then the law does not state that it is permissible to transgress the law.”

The police and the accused activists declined to comment.

Seja aliada da Pública

Faça parte do nosso novo programa de apoio recorrente e promova jornalismo investigativo de qualidade. Doações a partir de R$ 10,00/mês.

This report was produced by Agência Pública, a non-profit investigative journalism agency based in Brazil. This is an edited translation of the original version, published in Portuguese here.

Reportagem republicada no site Latin American Bureau.

Comentários de nossos aliados

 Ver comentários

Esta é a área de comentários dos nossos aliados, um espaço de debate para boas discussões sobre as reportagens da Pública. Veja nossa política de comentários.

Carregando…
Você precisa ser um aliado para comentar.
Fechar
Só aliados podem denunciar comentários.
Fechar

Explore também

Edward Luz, o antropólogo que tem posicionamentos radicais e contrários aos direitos dos povos indígenas

O antropólogo dos ruralistas

7 de dezembro de 2015 | por

Desligado da Associação Brasileira de Antropologia em 2013, Edward Luz promete apresentar 32 denúncias à Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito da Funai e do Incra

“Eles estão roubando vocês!”

8 de maio de 2014 | por

Em livro recém-lançado no Brasil, o jornalista britânico Andrew Jennings desnuda farsa de ingressos da Copa e avisa: os brasileiros estão pagando por uma Copa que só trará lucro para Fifa e patrocinadores. Confira aqui a entrevista e trecho do livro em primeira mão.

20 projetos de lei no Congresso pretendem criminalizar fake news

11 de maio de 2018 | por

Para especialistas, criar novo tipo de crime não resolve o problema e abre espaço para abusos e censura

Mais recentes

Manifestações podem definir futuro de Bolsonaro no Congresso

24 de maio de 2019 | por

A Pública conversou com parlamentares sobre a crise entre governo e Congresso; ceticismo predomina, mas o resultado das ruas no dia 26 terá peso decisivo no futuro dessas relações

Dois anos do massacre de Pau D’Arco: mandantes ainda impunes e ameaça de despejo

24 de maio de 2019 | por

Em entrevista à Pública, a advogada Andréia Silvério, da CPT de Marabá, conta que os sobreviventes da chacina que vitimou dez trabalhadores ocupantes da fazenda Santa Lúcia em Pau D’Arco (PA) não receberam nenhum apoio do Estado, e que novos conflitos são iminentes

Influenciadores da direita relatam linchamentos virtuais de bolsonaristas

24 de maio de 2019 | por e

Ataques organizados partem de grupos de WhatsApp: “Vamos dar uma oprimida” é a palavra de ordem para as “hienas”

Login para aliados

Participe e seja aliado.

Fechar